The traditional politician’s fallacy runs as:
1. Something must be done.
2. This is something.
3. Therefore, this must be done.
Amazing how many health-care discussions follow exactly this pattern:
1. The health care system in the US has problems and there are many ways in which it could be changed for the better.
2. Congress and Obama are proposing to change the health care system.
3. Therefore, we need to be ready to support whatever change will come out of Congress.
*
This is embedded into the question “Do you support health care reform?” which is, properly speaking, a trick question. It seems to be asking whether you agree with proposition 1, but it really asks for support of proposition 3.